Dustre
EN
Customer area

4140 vs 4340 steel: differences and when to use

4340 is a 4140 with about 1.8 % nickel. Nickel increases hardenability and toughness: quenched and tempered 4340 keeps core hardness in larger sections and resists impact better. 4140 (Cr-Mo) is cheaper and suits shafts, pins and gears of medium section.

4140 vs 4340 steel
PropertySAE 4140SAE 4340
Identification
GroupCarbon and alloy steelsCarbon and alloy steels
UNSG41400G43400
W.Nr. / EN42CrMo4 – 1.7225 (EN ISO 683-2)≈ 34CrNiMo6 – 1.6582 (EN ISO 683-2); ≈ 36CrNiMo4 – 1.6511
Chemical composition (%)
C0.38 – 0.430.38 – 0.43
Mn0.75 – 1.000.60 – 0.80
Si0.15 – 0.350.15 – 0.35
P≤ 0.035≤ 0.035
S≤ 0.040≤ 0.040
Cr0.80 – 1.100.70 – 0.90
Ni–1.65 – 2.00
Mo0.15 – 0.250.20 – 0.30
Febalancebalance
Composition: standardSAE J404 / ASTM A29SAE J404 / ASTM A29
Mechanical properties (minimum)
Yield strength––
Tensile strength––
Elongation––
Hardness––
Properties: conditionQuenched and tempered, section Ø 40–100 mm (EN 10083-3 / ISO 683-2, 42CrMo4 +QT); properties fall as the section increasesQuenched and tempered, section Ø 40–100 mm (reference 34CrNiMo6 +QT, EN 10083-3 / ISO 683-2)
Use and supply
PREN (minimum – typical)––
Density––
Service temperatureUp to ≈ 400–450 °C without relevant loss of properties (always below the tempering temperature).Up to ≈ 400 °C in structural service, always below the tempering temperature.
Standards by product formBar (composition): SAE J404 / ASTM A29 / ABNT NBR NM 87
Quenched and tempered bar: ASTM A434 (classes BB, BC, BD)
Forging: ASTM A668 / API 6A (75K) to customer specification
Mechanical tubing: ASTM A519
Plate: ASTM A829
Bar (composition): SAE J404 / ASTM A29
Quenched and tempered bar: ASTM A434
Aerospace bar/forging: AMS 6414 (VAR) / AMS 6415
Forging: ASTM A668 / to customer specification
Mechanical tubing: ASTM A519
Typical applicationsShafts, spindles and axle shafts
Oil and gas forgings (bodies, bonnets, hangers – API 6A 75K)
ASTM A193 B7 / B7M and A320 L7 studs and bolts (including for Petrobras)
Quenched and tempered or nitrided gears and pinions
Large-section shafts and spindles
Heavy transmission gears and crown wheels
Landing gear and aircraft structural components (VAR)
Highly stressed crankshafts and connecting rods

Composition and minimum properties per the standard listed on each datasheet; PREN uses the minimum and the middle of the ranges. For the actual value, use the heat certificate.

Quote these materials

Most searched comparisons

For pitting resistance, see the PREN calculator; for steel weldability, the carbon equivalent; to choose by medium, steel by corrosive medium.

Frequently asked questions

Which one for a large shaft?

For large diameters, with core hardness or impact requirements, 4340. For medium sections, 4140 usually does the job.

Do both weld well?

Both need preheating and hydrogen control; 4340, with a higher carbon equivalent, needs more care. See the carbon equivalent calculator.

Can I replace 4140 with 4340?

Yes, 4340 works wherever 4140 works. Adjust tempering to the hardness specified on the drawing.

HelenaVirtual assistant · WhatsApp

Request a quote

Subject: . Fill in and send: your request goes to our technical team and we reply by email.

More details (optional): tax ID, delivery, deadline and requirements
Requirements

Drawing, list or specification. Up to 5 files and 15 MB in total.

Send via WhatsApp

We use your data only to answer this quote. Privacy. · WhatsApp +55 11 98649-0075 · Mon–Thu 07:00–17:00 · Fri 07:00–16:00 (Brasília time)